Empirical research of advantage disciplines of C9 League | |
QI Yan; LEI Bingxu; XU Haiyun; FANG Shu | |
刊名 | chinese journal of library and information science |
2013-12-25 | |
卷号 | 6期号:4页码:79-96 |
关键词 | Discipline evaluation University evaluation Scientific assessment Evaluation index |
ISSN号 | 1674-3393 |
通讯作者 | xu haiyun (e-mail:xuhy@clas.ac.cn) |
中文摘要 |
purpose: based on the case of the top nine elite universities in china (i.e. c9 league), we evaluate the university discipline advantages in terms of outputs and influence of scientific articles. combining with the discipline collaboration analysis, we provide suggestions on discipline development and future collaboration for c9 league members. design/methodology/approach: first, we carry out a correlation analysis. then, we obtain the new combination evaluation indicators through factor analysis on seven primary indicators from incite platform. afterwards, we assign the weighted values to different indicators in order to get the evaluation scores and the ranking for each c9 league member. then, we obtain the bibliographic data of the c9 league members for extracting the category classifications from the web and transforming them into degree-granting and personal trainning courses catalogue (dptcc). according to the original collaboration frequencies among c9 league members, we carry out the analysis on two-mode collaboration networks. finally, we propose some suggestions on the future collaboration and development. findings: there is correlation relationship between the outputs of scientific papers and influence indicators, so it is necessary to use the various indicators to acquire the more scientific evaluation. meanwhile, league members are different in the discipline development level, and have inadequate collaboration with each other, which indicates that there exists the great potential for further collaborations. research limitations: despite the relative high quality sci papers, preference for different disciplines of sci and different discipline features for c9 members probably exert negative influence on evaluation results. practical implications: we provide a research thought and an operational approach to the disciplines evaluation, which would promote more methods for scientific discipline evaluation and reasonable management for universities. originality/value: there are more and more articles on the universities evaluation indexes, but rarely on the relationship among the indicators. therefore, our approach would be helpful for the evaluation of university disciplines. |
英文摘要 |
purpose: based on the case of the top nine elite universities in china (i.e. c9 league), we evaluate the university discipline advantages in terms of outputs and influence of scientific articles. combining with the discipline collaboration analysis, we provide suggestions on discipline development and future collaboration for c9 league members. design/methodology/approach: first, we carry out a correlation analysis. then, we obtain the new combination evaluation indicators through factor analysis on seven primary indicators from incite platform. afterwards, we assign the weighted values to different indicators in order to get the evaluation scores and the ranking for each c9 league member. then, we obtain the bibliographic data of the c9 league members for extracting the category classifications from the web and transforming them into degree-granting and personal trainning courses catalogue (dptcc). according to the original collaboration frequencies among c9 league members, we carry out the analysis on two-mode collaboration networks. finally, we propose some suggestions on the future collaboration and development. findings: there is correlation relationship between the outputs of scientific papers and influence indicators, so it is necessary to use the various indicators to acquire the more scientific evaluation. meanwhile, league members are different in the discipline development level, and have inadequate collaboration with each other, which indicates that there exists the great potential for further collaborations. research limitations: despite the relative high quality sci papers, preference for different disciplines of sci and different discipline features for c9 members probably exert negative influence on evaluation results. practical implications: we provide a research thought and an operational approach to the disciplines evaluation, which would promote more methods for scientific discipline evaluation and reasonable management for universities. originality/value: there are more and more articles on the universities evaluation indexes, but rarely on the relationship among the indicators. therefore, our approach would be helpful for the evaluation of university disciplines. |
学科主题 | 编辑出版 |
资助信息 | this work is supported by the west light foundation of chinese academy of science (grant no.y4c0011001) |
原文出处 | http://www.chinalibraries.net |
公开日期 | 2014-02-26 |
内容类型 | 期刊论文 |
源URL | [http://ir.las.ac.cn/handle/12502/6708] |
专题 | 文献情报中心_Journal of Data and Information Science_Chinese Journal of Library and Information Science-2013 |
推荐引用方式 GB/T 7714 | QI Yan,LEI Bingxu,XU Haiyun,et al. Empirical research of advantage disciplines of C9 League[J]. chinese journal of library and information science,2013,6(4):79-96. |
APA | QI Yan,LEI Bingxu,XU Haiyun,&FANG Shu.(2013).Empirical research of advantage disciplines of C9 League.chinese journal of library and information science,6(4),79-96. |
MLA | QI Yan,et al."Empirical research of advantage disciplines of C9 League".chinese journal of library and information science 6.4(2013):79-96. |
个性服务 |
查看访问统计 |
相关权益政策 |
暂无数据 |
收藏/分享 |
除非特别说明,本系统中所有内容都受版权保护,并保留所有权利。
修改评论